
Did you know
Tight 69-minute runtime — shorter than most television pilots.

"HORROR stalking its halls!"
The Good Comrades are a collection of varied gentlemen who crave one thing - solitude. They reside at Drearcliff House, ancestral home of their eldest member. All seems serene and convivial until one by one the members begin to perish in the most grisly of manners. Foul play is suspected by the Good Comrades' insurance agent, who turns to Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson for guidance.
“HORROR stalking its halls!”

Basil Rathbone
Sherlock Holmes

Nigel Bruce
Dr. John Watson

Aubrey Mather
Alastair

Paul Cavanagh
Simon Merrivale

Dennis Hoey
Inspector Lestrade

Harry Cording
John Simpson

Holmes Herbert
Alan Cosgrave

Sally Shepherd
Mrs. Monteith
Credits
Want more? Switch to Cinephile mode in the header for DP, composer, budget, box office, production companies, keywords, and release history.
Did you know?
Cinephile deep dive
Roy William Neill directs. Virgil Miller behind the camera. Paul Sawtell scores. Saul A. Goodkind cuts. Runs lean at under 100 minutes. Produced in United States of America. Dialogue in English.
Trivia
Part of
A series of fourteen films based on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes stories was released between 1939 and 1946; the British actors Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce played Holmes and Dr. John Watson, respectively. The first two films in the series were produced by 20th Century Fox and released in 1939. The studio stopped making the films after these, but Universal Pictures acquired the rights from the Doyle estate and produced a further twelve films. Although the films from 20th Century Fox had large budgets, high production values, and were set in the Victorian era, Universal updated the films to the contemporary era of the Second World War, and produced them as B pictures with lower budgets. Both Rathbone and Bruce continued their roles when the series changed studios, as did Mary Gordon, who played the recurring character, Mrs. Hudson.














Also by
Trailers & featurettes
Community reviews
When an insurance man calls upon Messrs. “Holmes” (Basil Rathbone) and “Watson” (Nigel Bruce) in their recently bullet-holed Baker Street lodgings, he raises some concerns about a group called the “good comrades”. They live in a remote, coastal and creepy, mansion house where each have made the others their beneficiaries in the event of their demise. Quite recently, two of them have bitten the dust and when “Holmes” hears that a certain “Dr. Merrivale” (Paul Cavanagh) is amongst them, they decide that they ought to pay these gents a visit. The whole shooting match is hosted by the dithery “Alistair” (Aubrey Mather) and the remainder of them could all be suspects too, but what could be the motive and what’s the significance of the decreasing numbers of orange pips delivered to each victim hours before they go the way of the dodo. Suspicions are duly aroused when the seafaring captain “Simpson” (Harry Cording) has a narrow escape with a needle and tensions only heighten when the hapless “Lestrade” (Dennis Hoey) shows up. With the big house creaking, the residents dwindling and a menacing black raven circling overhead, our two sleuths have their work cut out for them. This is one of the more complex stories for our detective duo, and Mather adds charmingly to the usual supporting cast that also benefits from Sally Shepherd’s housekeeper playing her cards very close to her chest. There are a few clues for us along the way, lots of misty and dingy, candle-lit, scenes and as ever, the pair deliver amiably throughout. Half a crown to deliver a letter? I should have been a postie!
Production companies

Universal Pictures
US
Themes & keywords
Release history · US
Also known as
Movie1943
Movie1944
Movie1943
Movie1983
Movie1939
Movie1985
Movie2016
Movie1987
Movie1965
Movie1988